19.07.2024 Atelier41 Summer Exhibition is a Tribute to David Fincher Movies : Forensic Aesthetics

The idea for this exhibition originated from the patient study of a group of 11 small contact prints, which stubbornly resisted analysis. These tiny silver gelatin prints were discovered 15 years ago at a famous New York flea market …

No images? Click here

FORENSIC AESTHETICS

Lot 5. Ralph Steiner Bissell’s Old Plant or Dungeon Documentation before destruction Grand Rapids, Michigan, 1959, a group of six vintage contact prints

Save the Date

“Forensic Aesthetics” will last two month until the auction on September 14 2024, 3 p.m. The catalog is available online on the Drouot.com, consigned.it and 150cent.com


Lot 6. Ralph Steiner Bissell’s Old Plant or Dungeon Documentation before destruction Grand Rapids, Michigan, 1959, a second group of six vintage contact prints

The idea for this exhibition originated from the patient study of a group of 11 small contact prints, which stubbornly resisted analysis. These tiny silver gelatin prints were discovered 15 years ago at a famous New York flea market by a well-known dealer, Lennicher, known as Lenny. Even back then, Lenny insisted they were significant and created by a very famous photographer, though he had forgotten the name. Despite their small size, he demanded a considerable sum for them.

The images depict an abandoned warehouse, focusing on details that seem like clues in a photographic investigation: keys hanging on a wooden board, wear marks on the floor, abandoned shoes, and an old radiator. For years, we searched to see if these corresponded to a famous criminal case, but they did not, not at all.


In fact, in 1959, the renowned magazine Fortune commissioned the great photojournalist Ralph Steiner to document the story of a wildly successful American company, Bissell’s vacuum cleaner factory. Steiner decided to narrate the story of American success by starting with the first vacuum cleaner factory in Michigan around 1880. In 1959, the building still existed, though it was no longer in use, and Steiner chose to employ the aesthetic of a detective or FBI photographer to conduct his investigation.

Thus, one of the world’s most famous photo magazines published these photographs with the aesthetic of forensic photographers. This implies that over roughly a century, from 1860 to 1960, the development of scientific police photography for solving mysteries, conducting investigations, and identifying criminals also created a distinct aesthetic category within the history of photography.


74. Ernest Appert. Aurore Hortense David (Machu wife) Prison des Chantiers, Versailles, 1871 Albumin print, 10.5×6 cm, on carte de viste card, identification in ink on mount.

Bertillonage

The repression of the 1871 Paris Commune marked a turning point in the use of photography by the police. The Prefecture of Police called on photographer Appert to take portraits of arrested Communards in the Versailles prisons. In the following years, although not systematically, the practice developed at the Prefecture de Police, in the urban police forces of a number of major cities, in the court clerks’ offices, and in some prisons and military jails. Portraits began to be included individual convict files, procedural files and the first index cards.


Lot 80. Police Judiciaire de Lyon. Félix Lemaitre, 15-year-old murderer, Lyon Prison, 1881, albumen print, 10.5×6 cm, on carte de viste cardboard, ink identification on mount, a few marginal stains, cardboard yellowed, traces of thumbtacks. This 15-year-old butcher’s apprentice, considered intelligent and fond of literature and music, steals 200 francs from his employer one day, and after a few days’ vacation in Paris, decides to buy a knife and look for a victim to sacrifice, which will be a six-year-old boy(alienist’s report below).

Now, how did he become an assassin? Here’s the story he told us:

“I wasn’t happy, my head was working. When I got out of lunch at two o’clock, I went for a walk on the boulevard, and then, all of a sudden, my head was spinning. I had a vision. My eyelids were fluttering, it was buzzing in my ears like a gnat. I was very strong on my feet, but I stopped because I couldn’t see clearly. I couldn’t walk anymore. I could see the trees, the houses, the whole world in red. My throat had suddenly gone dry.

I was speechless for at least eing minutes. I had no idea I was going to fall, I just stood there until it passed. It had taken hold of me all of a sudden like a dizziness takes hold of you. I was walking around, but I didn’t feel the same as usual. It was like a silent rage. It was nearly three o’clock. While thinking of nothing, I had the idea of killing someone. I fought for a long time, thinking about my parents and everyone else. Then I went back to my room, sat down, had a smoke and read a bit to see if the idea would pass. I was very restless and wandered up and down the room, but then I suddenly started cursing: “Holy God, I’ve got to kill someone! So I got my knife ready, opened it wide, put it in my dresser drawer and went down to the street. There were only kids there. I walked around for half an hour, waiting for someone bigger.

I didn’t hear a voice, but inside me it was like a thirst for blood.I finally approached the first little boy and asked him to follow me to my room to run an errand for me and take some laundry to the laundress. He seemed to have made up his mind, but ran off. I approached two others: one said he couldn’t, because his mother was waiting for him; the other, on the offer of my steel chain, agreed to follow me.

I let him in, double-locked the door, took off my overcoat, tied his hands behind his back and rolled up a towel to close his mouth. I saw that it was too big, that it wouldn’t hold, so I took my scarf and gagged him. He didn’t say anything; he looked astonished. I took him in my arms and laid him on the bed. I was upset, I had a fever, I was shaking, I was chattering my teeth like when you have a cold.

I didn’t care at all to see him on the bed; he didn’t struggle, move or try to escape. I undid his jacket and vest, undid his pants and lifted up his shirt, put my left hand over his eyes, took my knife, which was in the chest of drawers, all open; I gave him two blows in the belly, just on the big gut that came out, and then I cut his throat across.


Lot 103. Alexandre Lacassagne. Tattoo on the torso of Corsican Antoine Magnani: Les dernières cartouches, April 25, 1901, vintage silver print, 18×24 cm, remarks reversed in the margin of the negative, readable in a mirror.

Based on the work of Cesare Lombroso, Alexandre Lacassagne theorized that “tattooing was the inaction resulting from imprisonment, coupled with the impossibility of expressing particularly important ideas and feelings in any other way”. Lacassagne collected more than 2,000 tattoos on the skin of 550 French convicts. His study made it possible to analyze the bodies of both prisoners and soldiers. The professor distinguished several categories of tattoos: patriotic and religious emblems (91), professional inscriptions (98), inscriptions (111), military emblems (149), metaphorical emblems (260), amorous and erotic (280), fanciful and historical (344).

Antoine Magnani, was sentenced to prison for the murder of André Berger, at Navara (com. de Sartène, Corsica), on November 2, 1894.

His tattoo depicts the Battle of Bazeilles on September 1, 1870, in particular the heroic scene of the division’s marsouins sacrificing themselves to save the French army, a scene immortalized by painter Alphonse de Neuville in his painting “Les dernières cartouches”.

Lot 109. Villars et Barthelemy, Epitalon, Boccon et GibodJ. Andanson, R. Melloul, D. Simon, M. Ginies. La Capture de Mesrine Paris, November 2, 1979, ten vintage silver prints, approx. 20×27 cm, agency stamps and descriptions on versos.

Jacques Mesrine, public enemy no. 1, was shot dead by police during an operation at Porte de Clignancourt, after a year and a half on the run.


Lot 38. American photojournalist, Crime Scene, 1950s, vintage color print on Kodak watermarked paper, 21×20 cm, no annotations on verso.


Lot 66. Unidentified American photographer, Mae Dae C. Received at Morgue, November 25, 1945, vintage silver print, 17×12 cm, annotations legible in the data sheet tucked behind the right hand, including the name of prime suspect Yourie Scott and the crime scene, 90 Navy road.

Forensic Aesthetics

From the morgues of Detroit and Puebla to those of New York and Mexico City, the American and Mexican schools of photography attempted to transcend the beauty and horror of violent death through photography and staging.


108. Joel David Kaplan, Photographer convicted for murder, Portraits of Bonnie Sharie, actresses, reportages, New York, 1955-1957. Fourteen vintage silver prints, various sizes, from 18×24 to 30×40 cm, photographer’s stamp on verso.

Joel David Kaplan, was a New York photographer then businessman and nephew of Molasses Tycoon Jacob M. Kaplan, whose J.M. Kaplan Fund was named in a 1964 congressional investigation as a conduit for CIA money for Latin America. Joel David Kaplan was convicted in 1962 for the Mexico City murder of his New York business partner, Louis Vidal Jr. Kaplan claimed at the trial that Vidal, who had been involved in narcotics and gunrunning, had constructed an elaborate plot to disappear.

The murder victim, Kaplan maintained, was not even Vidal, and indeed, serious doubts were raised about the body’s identity. Kaplan escaped from his Mexican Jail in August 1971, accompanied by Carlos Antonio Contreras Castro, a Venezuelan counterfeiter. Most of the 136 guards at Mexico City’s Santa Maria Acatitla prison were watching a movie with the prisoners when a Bell helicopter, similar in color to the Mexican attorney general’s, suddenly clattered into the prison yard. Some of the guards on duty presented arms, supposing that the helicopter had brought an unexpected official visitor.

The final escape plans – Kaplan had prepared many plans which all failed during the years – had apparently been completed the day before when an American man visited Cell No. 10 and looked over the prison yard. He was accompanied by both men’s wives. (Kaplan had married a Mexican woman—the only way he could have visitors, he said—without bothering to divorce New York Model Bonnie Sharie.)

After the escape, Kaplan and Castro switched to a small Cessna at a nearby airfield and were flown to La Pesca airport near the Texas border, where two more planes awaited them. One flew Castro to Guatemala; the other flew Kaplan to Texas and then on to California. Kaplan used his own name when he passed U.S. customs at Brownsville. Both the helicopter, which was later found abandoned, and the Cessna had been bought in the U.S., at an estimated cost of $100,000. At week’s end neither man had been caught. Kaplan’s Mexican attorney declared that his client was a CIA agent and that the rescue had been engineered by the agency. The jail break was so notorious it was even featured in the Charles Bronson film Breakout and became the subject of examinations of conspiracy theories. Kaplan died in Miami in 1988.

Delivery and shipping

ASTA DI SENIGALLIA is based in Senigallia, Italy, its headquarters and showroom. Consignments, inquiries, assistance and shipping are generated from the ATELIER41 center, located at Via Fratelli Bandiera 41, 60019 Senigallia (AN).

The ATELIER41’s team is at your disposal to welcome you, answer your questions, and provide additional images.

Lots can be picked up in Senigallia, Châtillon-sur-Saône, Paris, or shipped by BRT, UPS or FedEx to third-party destinations.

Offline Auction process

If you do not have internet access, do not wish to register with Drouot, or simply prefer to remain anonymous, ATELIER41 offers an Offline Auction process.

To proceed, you may contact the ATELIER41’s team, by e-mail to consigned, or in person at ATELIER41, Via Fratelli Bandiera 41, 60019 Senigallia (AN), Italy.

La Fotografia antica è la più bella delle collezioni …

Senigallia, città della fotografia, ospita un nuovo spazio dedicato alla collezione di fotografie. Atelier 41, si trova 41 via fratelli Bandiera. In preparazione la IV Biennale di Senigallia, estate 2025, conferenza, fiera 13-15 Giugno 2023.

Senigallia diventerà la Città delle collezioni.

Share
Tweet
Share
Forward

ATELIER 41
Via Fratelli Bandiera 41
60019 Senigallia
ItalyPreferences | Unsubscribe

CATALOGO-ASTA-FORENSIC-LIGHT

CATALOGO-ASTA-FORENSIC-HD

 

Leave a Reply